The Electorate's Ability to Swallow the Biggest of Untruths

Wear your anorak proudly here! The place to discuss website & forum developments, administration, wish-lists, bugs, abuse etc

Moderator: frenzarin

Post Reply
JGD
Posts: 751
Joined: 5 Feb 2018 11:39
Location: Perry Hill, SE6 (yup that's Catford)
Contact:

The Electorate's Ability to Swallow the Biggest of Untruths

Post by JGD »

Well, none of us can say we didn't know it was inaccurate.

And we don't get the benefit of ignorance, we know that the man who said it has a history of lies and exaggeration.

And that we knew he felt he could embellish his position by saying it in such a flamboyant way that demonstrated he did not give a flying fernickety for falsehoods foisted on potential voters.

But we all have to swallow now - and hard.

The Indie carries this Treasury statement:
The Treasury has confirmed that it will not be getting an extra £350 million a week after Britain stops paying into the EU budget, despite false claims by Brexiteers during the referendum.

Britain is in fact expected to be overall poorer by £1,200 per person because of Brexit's economic drag, according to the government's spending watchdog.

The chancellor's red budget book shows the gross EU contributions saved by the UK will be around £42 billion over the next five years, rather than the £91 billion claimed under the false figure publicised by Boris Johnson in 2016.
So for clarity, this total of £42,000,000,000 (£42 Bn) over five years equates to £161,500,000 (£161.5 m) per week which is not the £350,000,000 (£350 m) promised in the telling of the lie.

The actualite tells us we don't get £350 m per week, which over 5 years is equivalent to £91,000,000,000.00 (£91 Bn).

We only get £42 Bn - a shortfall of £49 Bn - and all on Tory Treasury figures too. Which also calculate it wil cost us £30 Bn in the short-term to stimulate and sustain the economy through the Covid-19 crisis. It is unknown what estimates for any medium and long-term support costs will be.

It is wonderful that democracy provides no money-back guarantee but then truth will out

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/p ... 95476.html

mosy
Posts: 3992
Joined: 21 Sep 2007 20:28
Location: London

Re: The Electorate's Ability to Swallow the Biggest of Untruths

Post by mosy »

The referendum wasn't just to decide whether to leave the EU because of the money the UK paid into it was it?

In fact the bus myth was busted in every headline for a week before the referendum. However, I reckon the reality is that people who weren't in favour of the EU and its rules at voting time would have voted to leave had the amount been a mere fifty quid so the amount was irrelevant. The NHS bus might have persuaded some waverers over to Leave and persuaded them to go out and vote but arguably it's waverers or Remainers who chose not to vote at all that lost the Remain vote.

Actually, the amount sent to the EU is peanuts in the total budget income and spending/borrowing of the UK government. People don't have the opportunity to complain/decide via a referendum about the misuse or ill-advised or unpopular use of the majority of funds elsewhere. If they did, half of government spending could be cut overnight ;)

JGD
Posts: 751
Joined: 5 Feb 2018 11:39
Location: Perry Hill, SE6 (yup that's Catford)
Contact:

Re: The Electorate's Ability to Swallow the Biggest of Untruths

Post by JGD »

An update.
JGD wrote:
12 Mar 2020 15:17
We only get £42 Bn - a shortfall of £49 Bn - and all on Tory Treasury figures too. Which also calculate it wil cost us £30 Bn in the short-term to stimulate and sustain the economy through the Covid-19 crisis. It is unknown what estimates for any medium and long-term support costs will be.
Reading reports that the HMG's support package with increased rescue costs cast at £330 Bn (revised upwards within days from £30 Bn) is now deemed to be foundering and it that will require further patching up.

Increasingly "vulture" banks have been bending the rules to maximise their own profits by insisting that business owners provide onerous personal financial guarantees as a condition of accessing the government’s Coronavirus Business Interruption Loan Scheme (CBILS) designed to provide interest free loans to businesses for 12 months. Funds that are designed to keep many companies afloat.

HMG on being alerted to the practice quickly stamped on it and have insisted that operational changes be made to speed up lending approvals.

HMG have demanded that banks radically simplify the application process, remove administrative hurdles and scale up lending to companies. Banks are no longer permitted to reject an application because of any lack of security on the borrower's part.

The Treasury announced on Thursday that 983 firms have now received support from CBILS, with £90m of lendings being approved. This from over 100,000 applications. This level of performance is of huge concern to HMG as its planned impact is being entirely dissipated.

HMG's announcements about large-scale schemes to assist businesses and the general populace are failing at implementation stages on several major streams.

CBILS failings and with further failings in Universal Credit where over 1m applications are overwhelming systems that will not and cannot cope with demand and issue material assistance to people, creates a very harsh reality at which HMG's inadequacies are at the heart.

HMG must take on-board the assistance and expertise that is genuinely needed and to desist from rejecting news and advice that emanates from sources outside their closed circles and for stupendously inept reasons like "they are not voices of our own".

The moment for seasoned disruptors who got elected in the last GE has ended abruptly.

The country is now in immediate and dire need of those with expertise and experience who can deliver change, systems and assistance methodically and effectively.

Post Reply